Below is an informal writing prompt to get students thinking about why punctuation matters. I recommend you use whatever technology is available to you so that you can read the prompt aloud while students follow along.
The informal prompt
Look at these two sentences about a sports competition and think about when someone might say each of them:
- May the best man win.
- May the best man win?
Consider: Under what circumstances would someone use sentence one? Under what circumstances would someone use sentence two?
In no more than four sentences, explain the differences between the meaning of the first sentence and the meaning of the second sentence. You have 1 minute to write your explanation.
Notes on this informal activity
Unlike an oral question, informal writing gets every member of a class to do something with the information that’s before them.
Because this informal writing activity activity is brief, uncomplicated, and deals with sports, it’s fairly easy to get students’ attention for the two minutes it takes to read the prompt and write a response. The activity may even hold the attention of students whose acquaintance with sports gives them a more extensive list of reasons why someone would wonder whether it is possible for the best competitor to win a contest.
Reading aloud while students follow along is recommended because, for a variety of reasons, many American teenage and adults students need help reading. Anything you can do to help them associate word forms with word sounds—even if its just a two-minute activity—is worth doing.