This afternoon was the meeting for panelists on teams to interview candidates for the superintendent’s job at Bainbridge-Guilford Central School District.
DCMO BOCES Superintendent William Tammaro began the session by telling us the BG board is interviewing six candidates this week, so we will not have information about the three finalists until next week.
Tammaro also said that he was instructed by the BG board to look for candidates that would come with the intent of staying five to 15 years. He said all six of the people the board is interviewing would come with the expectation of staying five or more years.
Tammaro gave us each packets of information that included a copy of the brochure used to recruit candidates for the job, which, as I reported earlier, was not available from the school’s website or the BOCES website last week.
The advance memo about the meeting said we’d be given information on questioning techniques. What Tammaro provided was a standard list of questions that are illegal to ask during an interview, which can be downloaded from dozens of places on the web. A couple of people on the panel with me might have been helped by some general suggestions about formulating interview questions.
He said each panel would have “about an hour” to interview candidates. He suggested we leave 10 minutes for a candidate to ask questions. He said he recommended we have 20 questions to fill the rest of the time. All candidates are to be asked the same initial questions, though follow-up questions can vary.
After each candidate interview, each of the five interview panels (teachers, support staff, students, administrative committee, and community members) is to draft an immediate report to the board of education. Although Tammaro did not say so, the report form says the reaction is to be unanimous. If it is not, a minority report can be attached to the majority report.
Each panel is to present its report in the form of a two-item questionnaire:
- What strengths do you believe this candidate has with regard to the Superintendency in Bainbridge-Guilford?
- To what extent do you see this candidate “fitting in” to the Superintendent’s position in Bainbridge-Guilford?
The panel of community members is scheduled to meet with candidates from 4:30 to 5:30 p.m., and the report must be delivered to the board by 6 p.m. That 30-minute time frame does not permit a particularly thoughtful response, even if the questions were designed to elicit one.
Asking only about a candidate’s strengths strikes me as potentially dangerous. A candidate may have several strengths that are canceled by serious weaknesses.
Moreover, I’m not sure that “fitting in” is what I want in a school leader. I don’t want someone who is going to make a religion of doing things differently. On the other hand, I don’t want a superintendent to fit in so well she or he disappears in the crowd.
Followers fit in.
People with low expectations fit in.
Superficial thinkers fit in.
Educators who don’t keep on learning fit in.
Administrators who don’t rock the boat fit in.
And folks who bring more than two dozen people to a two-hour meeting to do a handful of tasks that could have been accomplished online in a few minutes fit in best of all.